The BP Chemicals site in Hull had for a long time suffered problems of leakage from its existing Girdlestone pumps. Although the exotic alloy pumps were reliable, the aqueous organic solution that was pumped at 150°C was very aggressive and tended to leak at the suction cover joint after a period of operation. As well as being a potential hazard this caused unplanned downtime for maintenance BP approached the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) for a solution but all that they could offer were direct replacement parts, thereby not re-solving the root cause of the problem. With the problem becoming more acute, BP approached Amarinth to see if a solution could be found.
Re-Engineering not Reverse Engineering
Amarinth already had experience in re-engineering components for Girdlestone pumps. Using powerful computer aided technologies such as 3D CAD, CFD and FEA, Amarinth was cost effectively designing components that not only replaced the OEM ones, but actually improved on them. Re-engineering is very different to the more well known reverse engineering which suffers from problems such as: Poor tolerance causing incorrect fit Inferior materials causing premature wear Warranty issues
As an example, an incorrect tolerance on a shaft can cause premature seal failure and so any savings gained from using a reverse engineered (or replicated) part are dwarfed by the un-scheduled replacement of another part.
Amarinth, being an OEM in its own right, understood the importance of correct fits and had re-engineered a number of parts for Girdlestone pumps, that improved on the design of the originals. Many of the Amarinth staff previously worked for Girdlestone and so using the latest technology could design out flaws from parts that had been designed up to 30 years ago.
Following an audit of the Amarinth operation, BP were fully convinced of its approach and decided to place an order for a re-engineering volute.
A single integrated component
Amarinth proposed a single integrated component consisting of the volute and the suction cover. This was designed to be dimensionally interchangeable with the original components so that no modifications were needed to the pump or the pipework. This new component was up-rated from 16 bar to 20 bar in order to match the rating of the flange and was radiographed and die penetrant tested.
Since fitting the new component there have been no further problems. BP has benefited from a re-engineered component that actually costs less than the equivalent pair of OEM parts, has reduced unplanned maintenance and prevented any further unforeseen leakages. The life of its expensive exotic alloy pump has been significantly extended.
BP was so pleased with the performance of the new integrated volute and suction cover that it immediately ordered another for its standby pump. Amarinth now supplies a range of spare parts to BP for many of its existing Girdlestone and Amarinth pumps on site.
Trade and industry bodies that Amarinth are either independently verified and accredited to, or members of: